© 2020 Iowa Public Radio
IPR20012_Website_Header_Option2_NewsNavy.png
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations
Agriculture

Farm States Still Struggling With Polluted Drinking Water

092816_Cities_Stange.jpg
BRIAN SEIFFERLEIN
/
Harvest Public Media file photo
Hastings, Nebraska, where Marty Stange (left) is environmental director, has implemented a successful approach to preventing nitrate pollution in drinking water.

A new analysis of drinking water systems shows communities in five Midwest states have legal but potentially worrying levels of nitrates. The Environmental Working Group (EWG) found nitrate levels in Iowa, Illinois, Kansas, and Oklahoma are trending up.

(The full report also includes California, Texas, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Maryland.)

Anne Schechinger, senior economics analyst for EWG and author of the report, says heavy rains may account for the spikes seen in some states during certain years. She also found nitrate problems are more frequent in communities with fewer residents, which sometimes have water supplies close to farm fields.

“Small systems are more likely to be rural and they’re more likely to be ground-water systems,” Schechinger says. “These smaller systems are way less likely to have nitrate removal treatment systems.” 

Schechinger says runoff from agricultural lands contributes to nitrates in drinking water supplies. 

She called out Nebraska for working creatively to slow the problem.

In Hastings, Nebraska, a new system removes nitrates before they enter the drinking water supply. 

“We’ve actually seen it clean up that area that we’re getting our water from,” says city environmental director Marty Stagne. “It’s actually cleaned up slightly faster than what we anticipated.”

Stange says a treatment system that would remove nitrates from drinking water before it is pumped out to users was prohibitively expensive for the community of 25,000 people. Instead, certain wells collect potentially polluted water, act as a filter and prevent the nitrates from moving on. The nutrient can be repurposed as fertilizer, which is often why it was applied to the land in the first place, and the clean water is then reinjected into the aquifer, which goes on to supply the wells that do provide drinking water.

“Instead of taking the water out, treating it, putting it in a tower or a reservoir, and then making sure you have backup power, and doing all these things so that you’re trying to make water to meet the public’s demand,” he says, “basically we’re using the aquifer as a giant storage tank, which is trulywhat it is.”

Stange says Hastings so far has invested about $15 million in the system and the estimates he’d seen for a treatment system to remove nitrates ran around $76 million. The city is prepared to spend more money if necessary but is also talking with other rural communities about how they might deploy similar technologies. 

Nitrate levels above 10 milligrams per liter (mg/L) have long been associated with blue baby syndrome. More recent research has shown a correlation with certain cancers, thyroid disease and birth defects even at levels below the 10 mg/L legal limit.

The EWG report looked at nitrate levels above 3 mg/L, which is what the Environmental Protection Agency considers naturally occurring.

Follow Amy on Twitter: @AgAmyinAmes